Skip to content
Don’t Get Spoked! 10 Common Bike Buying Mistakes (And How to Avoid Them)
So, you’re finally getting a bike—congrats! Soon, you’ll be gliding through the city, feeling the wind in your hair, and wondering why you didn’t do this sooner. But before you take that victory lap, let’s make sure you don’t fall into one of these all-too-common bike-buying blunders.
1. Falling for the “Pretty but Painful” Trap
We know—a sleek, neon-colored frame practically screams Instagram-worthy. But a bike should do more than just look good.
- A gorgeous bike with a terrible ride is like a designer shoe that gives you blisters.
- Consider the fit, function, and feel before making it all about aesthetics.
A $200 bike might photograph as well as a $2,000 one, but trust us, your knees will know the difference.
Not all bikes are created equal, so opt for a bike that suits your needs! Remember, a $200 bike photographs just as nicely as a $10,000 bike, but it's important to understand what's "under the hood".
2. Thinking One Size Fits All (Spoiler: It Doesn’t)
Buying a bike without considering size is like buying jeans without trying them on—risky business.
- Measure twice, buy once: Your height and inseam determine the right frame size.
- Adjustability is your friend: Look for bikes with tweakable seats and handlebars.
Sizing is NOT universal across bike brands nor bike models. Each bike has its own geometry so measuring your inseam is key to a proper fit. Check out our video on how to accurately measure your inseam.
3. Not Matching the Bike to Your Life
What’s your riding vibe—city commutes, weekend joyrides, or off-road escapades? Your bike should fit your lifestyle, not just your apartment decor.
- City cruiser? Think comfort and upright seating.
- Long-distance adventurer? You’ll want lightweight and efficient gearing.
- Speed demon? Road bikes with drop bars are your jam.
With so many options on the market, it's easy to get lost in the bike-buying shuffle. Don't just pick what looks cool—pick what works for you. Our FREE Bike Buying Guide offers six MUST-KNOW tips before buying your next bike.
4. Skimping on Quality to Save Money
The False Economy of Cheap Bikes
Sure, budget matters. But cutting corners on quality will cost you more in repairs (and frustration).
- A well-made bike lasts longer and rides better.
- Bargain bikes often need constant maintenance—and that gets old fast.
Invest wisely, and your future self will thank you.
Just like choosing style over substance, skimping on quality to save money upfront will create headaches in the long run. Do your due diligence and opt for a bike that meets your needs and uses good-quality components.
5. Forgetting the Must-Have Extras
A bike alone won’t cut it. You’ll need a few accessories to actually use it.
- Safety first: Helmets, lights, and locks are non-negotiable.
- Comfort counts: Padded seats and ergonomic grips make a world of difference.
Many states require lights and bells—so why not make sure you’re legal and comfortable?
Invest in good-quality riding essentials like helmets, lights, and bells. These are commonly required by state law, but are always the best practice to keep you safe. While you're at it, check out our Safe Riding Guide featuring 5 tips for safe bicycle riding.
6. Not Doing Your Homework
Buying the first bike you see is a rookie move. A little research goes a long way:
- Read reviews (the good and bad ones) and learn from others' experiences.
- Compare specs across brands.
- Ask questions—bike shops and customer service teams exist for a reason.
- Use that live chat or support phone number.
There are so many options out there! Take your time while researching, and don't be hesitant to reach out with questions. Schedule a free one-on-one consultation call where we'll take the time to dive into your needs and use case, and provide guidance regarding which of our models might best meet your needs.
7. Picking the Wrong Type of Bike
Just because your friend swears by their gravel bike doesn’t mean it’s right for you.
- Commuting? Consider commuter or hybrid bike.
- Exploring trails? A hybrid bike is your match.
- Comfort-focused? A comfortable cruiser built for recreational riding is your friend.
Need a shortcut? With only four questions, our Bike Finder Quiz will match you with the right bike for your use case. Find your perfect ride in minutes.
8. Forgetting That Bikes Need TLC
Love your bike, and it’ll love you back.
- Regular maintenance keeps it running smoothly.
- Basic fixes—like changing a flat—are easy to learn and will save you when you're stranded.
9. Getting Sticker Shock and Settling for Less
Yes, bike prices can make you gulp. But think beyond the price tag:
- Quality components mean fewer breakdowns.
- Warranty and post-purchase support matter.
- Assembly and service costs can sneak up on you.
Buy the best bike for you, not just the cheapest one.
We get it- price is important! When researching consider things like quality of components used, warranty and support, assembly costs, and post-purchase support.
10. Not Buying a Brooklyn Bike (Sorry, We Had To)
Okay, we might be biased—but here’s the deal:
- Over 1,200 verified five-star reviews.
- Professional assembly included—because assembling bikes should not be a DIY project.
- Free shipping, easy returns, and lifetime customer support.
With free shipping & free professional assembly among the differentiators, read 7 Reasons Why You NEED a Brooklyn Bike.
Final Thoughts: Ride Smarter, Not Harder
Avoiding these 10 common mistakes can make your bike-buying journey as smooth as a freshly paved road. Remember, the right bike isn't just about the wheels and frame; it's about how it fits into your life and makes you feel when you're riding it. So, measure, research, and choose wisely—then get ready to roll.
Shop Best Sellers
View All
We build bikes for vivid lives—for taking adventures, reconnecting with old friends, discovering new neighborhoods and exploring hidden gems. Inspired by the streets of Brooklyn, our bikes are built for style, comfort, and durability. Made with top quality parts, crafted with care, and sold at an affordable price, your bike is yours for life. We scrutinize every component for maximum sustainability and performance, and every millimeter of the frame for ultimate comfort and style. We take pride in our process, in our products, and in the people who sell them.
Related Articles
- The Ultimate Guide to Hybrid Bikes: Everything You Need to Know
- Best Bikes for Carrying a Child Seat: Safe, Easy, and Fun Rides for Parents
- Why Dutch Bikes Are the Effortlessly Cool Choice for City Cycling
- Riding the Waves in Style: Why the Beach Cruiser Bike Is Always Catching a Break
- Stay Seen, Stay Safe: The Best Bike Lights for Commuting
